Walking Away

 

There is a short story that was written in 1973 by Ursula Le Guin called, “The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas.” Sam has shared and referenced this piece rather frequently over the past few months. It came up again in a recent email conversation among a few friends regarding this recent episode of This American Life, where Mr. Daisey travels to China to find out who makes all of our Mac crap and shares what he saw and what he learned.

I will not try to describe “Omelas” to you, for my attempt would be futile no doubt. And besides, that would rob you of the experience of reading it for yourself. It is short after all. The story ends with this line:

But they seem to know where they are going, the ones who walk away from Omelas.

In some ways, “Omelas” reminds me of the much more well-known poem by Frost, “The Road Not Taken.” The problem with something being well-known – be it a holy book, a poem, a movie – is that we think we know what it says when the reality is that we have most likely focused on one part at the expense of the whole. That one part in Frost’s poem is certainly the final stanza.

I shall be telling this with a sigh
Somewhere ages and ages hence:
Two roads diverged in a wood, and I -
I took the one less traveled by,
And that has made all the difference.

That decisions was not reached lightly, though, for the first half of the poem recounts the traveller in the process of deciding which way to take, looking down each road as far as he (or she) could. The final line of “Omelas” appears to have more certainty than Frost’s poem, but I think when you read both you will see that neither decision is reached lightly. It is only after the mind has been made as to the path to take that one can walk confidently – both away from something and toward something.

I don’t know what you need to walk away from. Heck, I don’t know what I need to walk away from, but after hearing Mr. Daisey’s piece, I feel pretty strongly that some other direction is needed. And when this direction is away from injustice it will certainly be the road less travelled.

Posted in Personal | 2 Comments

Constantine and the Bishops

One of the books I am reading this semester for my Christianity in Late Antiquity class is Constantine and the Bishops: The Politics of Intolerance, by H. A. Drake. As my fellow classmates are quickly learning I place a high value on appropriately nuanced arguments and explanations. Occam’s razor may work in many circumstances, but it rarely satisfies when doing history. Drake’s book, coming in at just under 500 pages with another 50 pages of notes, meets this criterion. What Drake does beyond this, though, and what makes his books indispensable, is the level of readability his work possesses.

Drake’s book is an example of history done well (i.e. it is well-researched, appropriately nuanced, does not accept easy traditional answers, and steers clear of anachronisms, both blatant and conceptual). Even with the scholarly acumen Drake exhibits I found myself immersed in the text as one does well-written novels. I even told a colleague that someone should make the book into a movie. It really is that engaging to read.

So, while I know you are not all as interested in 4th century Christianity and the social, economic, and political realities that made Constantine’s famous actions possible, I must still highly recommend this book. The Virginia Quarterly Review offered this nugget for the back cover:

If you read one book on late antiquity this year, read this one. If you read one book on politics this year, read this one again.

I couldn’t say it any better myself.

Posted in Religion | Leave a comment

New Site

trinitywhitley.com: experiencing life, exploring Tallahassee, and trying to minister along the way.

My wife Trinity has been toying with the idea of blogging for some time now and has (finally) decided to use her domain name that I’ve had for a while now. She’s writing about crafting stuff, her new life as a presbyterian, and many other random gems. She’s got a nice little design going on too. So, head over and check it out.

Posted in Personal | Leave a comment

1 Semester Down, Many More to Go

Things have been quiet here for a few weeks with the holidays, my wife moving to join me in Florida and a lot of travelling, packing, unpacking, and preparing for the semester which started today. This is my second semester as a PhD student and things really are going great.

Because I know some of you are interested in these types of things, I thought I’d give a quick rundown of my classes this semester.

Aramaic
This promises to be a great language class as I learn Aramaic (in just one semester). Aramaic’s many similarities to Hebrew make learning it significantly easier than just any other language. By the end of the semester I should have translated all of the Aramaic portions of Daniel (roughly half the book) as well as at least some of the Genesis Apocryphon, an Aramaic text found in Cave 1 of Qumran.

Rabbinic Judaism
This course serves as an introduction to the rabbinic literature of late antiquity. Most of our reading will be from the Babylonian Talmud and Genesis Rabbah. The readings will all be in English, but knowing Dr. Levenson we will spend plenty of time focusing on the Hebrew and Aramaic versions, at least as reference resources. I’m extremely excited about this class and the potential to how it allows for a better and more thorough understanding of the 1st century world.

Hebrew Bible Proseminar
This is a seminar on the Hebrew Bible (Old Testament) which will focus on the history of scholarship surrounding the HB and various critical approaches to the text. I’m particularly interested in the section on scribal culture as it relates to the HB.

Christianity in Antiquity
This is the followup class to last semester’s Christianity After the New Testament. Mostly we’ll be dealing with 4th and 5th century Christianity with the majority of our time spent with primary texts, though we will also be spending a healthy amount of time studying the rise of saints and monks during these years. This is much more my area (early Christianity) so I am naturally looking forward to this course.

I am also TAing an Intro to the New Testament course for Dr. Levenson. And when you add on a likely weekly Josephus Greek reading group my semester will be quite busy. I wouldn’t have it any other way.

Posted in Personal, Religion | 1 Comment

Tower of Song

After Targuman posted this picture on Twitter, which he aptly titled “Birds on a Wire,” I immediately thought of the Leonard Cohen song “Bird on a Wire” and switched my iTunes to Willie Nelson’s version. I am now listening to the entire album, titled Tower of Song: Songs of Leonard Cohen, again. It is heartfelt music with lyrics that contain depth, religious undertones, and an introspection rarely matched. I don’t listen to entire albums much anymore with the advent of Pandora and shuffle listening, but this is an album that, when I listen to it, I always do so entirely.

If you’ve never listened to the album, go do it now. Seriously. Leonard Cohen is a genius and this album is a collection of his songs as done by the likes of Willie Nelson, U2, Elton John, Bono, Tori Amos, and Suzanne Vega.

Also, Leonard Cohen is releasing a new album soon that is expected to be just as brilliant as his previous work. Check it out.

Posted in Personal | Leave a comment